Skip to main content

Tricks of the Trade: Self-Editing Checklist

Here is a handy checklist from Self-Editing for Fiction Writers by Renni Browne and Dave King. This is a book I recommend to my editing clients and something I like to look at for my own work every so often.

• How many ing and as phrases do you write? Remember, the only ones that count are the ones that place a bit of action in a subordinate clause.

• How about ly adverbs? Both tied to your dialogue and within your descriptions and narration.

• Do you have a lot of short sentences, both within your dialogue and within your description and narration?

• Do you use a lot of italics? We mean a lot of italics. And you don’t use many exclamation points, do you?!!

• Are there any metaphors or flowery phrases you’re particularly proud of. Do they come at key times during your plot? If so, think about getting rid of them.

• How much time have you spent moving your characters around? Do you cut from location to location, or do you fill in all the space in between?

• How much detail have you included in describing our character’s action? Try cutting some of the detail and see if the actions are still clear.

• Take a look at your flashbacks. How often are you interrupting the forward flow of your story? Do you have flashbacks at more than one level—that is, flashbacks from flashbacks? It you spend nearly as much time in the past as in the present, take a look at each flashback individually. If it were cut, would the present story be hard to follow?

• Keep in mind what you’re trying to do with each paragraph—what character point you’re trying to establish, what sort of mood you’re trying to create, what background you’re trying to suggest. In how many different ways are you accomplishing each of these?

• If more than one way, try reading the passage without the weakest approach and see if it isn’t more effective.

• Do you have more than one chapter that accomplishes the same thing?

• Is there a plot device or stylistic effect you are particularly pleased with? How often do you use it?

• Keep a lookout for unintentional word repeats. The more striking a word or phrase is, the more jarring it will be if you repeat it.


A native Montanan, Heidi Thomas now lives in Northwest Washington. She has had her first novel published, Cowgirl Dreams, based on her grandmother. Heidi has a degree in journalism, a certificate in fiction writing, and is a member of Northwest Independent Editors Guild. She teaches writing and edits, blogs, and is working on the next books in her “Dare to Dream” series. The sequel, Follow the Dream will be released this fall.
Bookmark and Share


  1. Excellent reminders, Heidi. I have really started not liking flashbacks or dreams as means of getting story points across. In my estimation they have been overused, and, like you said, they can sometimes stop the flow of the present action for too long. Sometimes it is hard to come up with an alternative, but writing is not easy. At least good writing isn't.

  2. " It you spend nearly "

    Do I get points for finding a typo in a piece about basic editing?

  3. All good points. Learning to spot them in your own work...that's the challenge!

    Terry's Place
    Romance with a Twist--of Mystery

  4. more great information for my binder!!! Thanks :)

  5. A lot of information! This makes a great list to keep handy as you edit your work.


  6. You're absolutely right, Maryann, it's not easy!

    anon: Yes, kudos for finding a typo! LOL

    Thanks all, for stopping by on a holiday!

  7. I came. I read. I scrolled and commented.
    Great info!

  8. I never tire of good information. Though I try to practice the items Heidi mentions, I find myself straying from the right path and find her reminders "course correctors" that keep me from hitting the shoals.

    Thank you, Heidi, for being so selfless and considerate.

  9. Hello Heidi,
    Thanks for this. I'll be sharing it with my critique group next Tues.

  10. will be bookmarking this list- very comprehensive and clear. Well done!

  11. Thanks for the editing checklist! It was very helpful for my writing.


Post a Comment

The Blood-Red Pencil is a blog focusing on editing and writing advice. If a glitch is preventing you from commenting, visit our Facebook page and drop your wise words there: Blood-Red Pencil on Facebook